Sapphire Vs. Diamond: Which Should You Choose?

Imagine two exquisite tiaras, one adorned with dazzling diamonds that twinkle like stars in the night sky and the other adorned with breathtaking sapphires that shimmer with an ethereal blue hue. If you were granted the chance to possess only one, which would you choose?

While some may have a resolute answer, others may find themselves caught in a captivating dilemma. If you find yourself torn between these magnificent treasures, allow me to present a concise comparative analysis, adding a touch of intrigue and excitement to your decision-making process.

What Are The Main Differences Between Sapphire & Diamond?

Composition

Diamond, a singular gem, consists solely of carbon, whereas sapphire represents a distinct variety of corundum, an aluminum oxide crystalline form.

Brilliance & Fire

When it comes to brilliance, which refers to the undispersed white light emitted by a gemstone, diamonds surpass sapphires with a refractive index of 2.42, while sapphires range between 1.76 and 1.77. As a result, diamonds exhibit greater brilliance and fire, showcasing a dazzling array of colorful flashes when illuminated by white light, compared to sapphires.

Origin & History

Diamond deposits, believed to be the oldest, emerged approximately 900 million years ago, deep within the Earth's mantle. Historical records indicate that diamonds were initially discovered in India and traded as early as the 4th century B.C. 

Since their unearthing, these precious gemstones have been highly sought after by royalty and the affluent. The ancient Greeks even attributed their formation to the tears of gods. Today, diamonds continue to captivate with their unrivaled brilliance, symbolizing love, fearlessness, and abundance.

Birthstone & Zodiac Sign

Diamonds, the official birthstone for April and the gemstone for the Aries zodiac sign hold a special place in the world of gifting. They are also the traditional choice for celebrating the 60th and 75th wedding anniversaries.

Sapphires, on the other hand, are esteemed as the official birthstone for September and the zodiac stone for the Virgo star sign. They make for a meaningful gift to mark the 5th and 45th wedding anniversaries, symbolizing enduring love and commitment.

Clarity

Sapphires often contain imperfections, including liquids, gases, and even crystals of other minerals. Inclusions are commonly found in diamonds, with the rarest and highest quality grade being F.L. (flawless).

Gemological Phenomenon

Sapphires possess pleochroism, which means they can showcase varying colors depending on the viewing angle. Additionally, certain sapphires exhibit asterism, resembling a star-like effect, and chatoyancy, resembling the appearance of a cat's eye.

In the case of some diamonds, such as chameleon diamonds, exposure to U.V. lamps can cause a remarkable color change.

Pricing

The cost of a high-quality sapphire can vary greatly, ranging from $50 to $10,000 per carat. Similarly, the price of a 1-carat diamond can start at $2,500 and climb as high as $30,000, depending on its quality.

Cut

The round cut is highly coveted for its ability to maximize the brilliance and fire of diamonds, making it the most sought-after shape. However, modern diamond cuts such as oval, emerald-cut, pear, cushion, and marquise are also popular choices.

Sapphires, on the other hand, offer a variety of shapes to choose from, including round, cushion, oval, emerald-cut, and pear.

Hardness

Diamonds, known as the hardest mineral to date, achieve a perfect 10/10 rating on the Mohs scale of hardness. In contrast, sapphires receive a different rating.

When considering affordability, diamonds tend to be more expensive. However, if you prefer a colorless/white diamond without breaking the bank, consider opting for Very Slightly Included (VS) diamonds with a grade of VS1 or VS2. It is advisable not to go below this grade.

In terms of size, sapphires are denser and heavier than diamonds. Consequently, even if they have the same weight, sapphires will appear smaller than a one-carat diamond. 

The price of sapphires also increases significantly once they reach the 5-carat mark. To enjoy the remarkable beauty of this gemstone, it is recommended to choose a sapphire ranging from 1 to 2 carats.

Why Should You Buy Sapphire?

Sapphires embody virtues such as nobility, sincerity, and wisdom, making them the perfect gemstone of choice. Not only are they synonymous with luxury and royalty, but when adorned with a sapphire ring, bracelet, necklace, or earrings, you will undoubtedly feel like royalty yourself!

Why Should You Buy Diamond?

A diamond, forever cherished as a woman's closest confidant, captivates with its exquisite brilliance, radiance, and unyielding resilience. This mesmerizing gem not only symbolizes eternal love but also bestows abundance and clarity upon its fortunate wearer. Whether adorning a ring, necklace, pendant, or earrings, bask in the luminosity and magnificence of a diamond that transcends time.

Where Should You Buy GIA-Certified Sapphire Or Diamond Jewelry From?

Discover a stunning collection of jewelry adorned with GIA-certified sapphires and diamonds, exclusively available at Solitaire Jewelers. These exquisite pieces are accompanied by a certificate from the renowned Gemological Institute of America, guaranteeing the authenticity and superior quality of each gem. 

The comprehensive report provides meticulous details about the gem's physical characteristics and any treatments applied, ensuring complete transparency in your purchase.

Moreover, our selection includes meticulously crafted rings and pendants featuring GIA-certified gems, boasting exquisite designs such as solitaire, halo, infinity, three-stone, vintage-inspired, and more. Experience the perfect blend of style and uncompromising quality.

Solitaire’s Collection Of Sapphire & Diamond Jewelry

Imagine a world where you can indulge in your dream sapphire and diamond jewelry without breaking the bank. At Solitaire Jewelers, we believe that jewelry is deeply personal - it reflects your unique style, personality, and story. That's why each piece is meticulously crafted to order, allowing you to select the perfect design, gemstone quality, carat weight, and metal to suit your individual taste.

To ensure your peace of mind, we provide a Certificate of Authenticity that includes all the necessary details of your gemstone, along with a Free Lifetime Warranty. Shop for your favorite gemstone jewelry with utmost confidence, knowing that we've got you covered.

Experience the joy of owning exquisite jewelry that resonates with your true self. Visit Solitaire Jewelers today, and let us bring your vision to life.

FAQs

Q1. What Does A Sapphire Look Like?

While sapphires are commonly linked with the color blue, these stunning gemstones actually showcase a captivating array of hues. From delicate pinks and pristine whites to vibrant yellows, oranges, greens, and even mesmerizing teals, sapphires offer a spectrum of colors that never fails to enchant.

Q2. Which Is More Expensive, Diamond Or Sapphire?

Sapphires come at a more affordable price compared to diamonds. A 1-carat sapphire of good quality can range from $50 to $10,000. On the other hand, the starting price for a fine-quality diamond is approximately $2,500, with the potential to reach as high as $30,000.

Q3. Where Do Sapphires Come From?

Sapphires are discovered in numerous locations across the globe. Some of the prominent sources of these precious gemstones include Burma, Kashmir, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Australia, Cambodia, China, Colombia, and the United States.